Cultural Appropriation vs. Appreciation: Where’s the Line?

Posted: 16th January 2025

Author: Gibendi Rael

By Gibendi Rael

Cultural diversity is crucial in shaping human experiences, as it enriches our understanding of the world. However, at the heart of it lies the risk of extinction, threatening to erase centuries of wisdom and identity that we have only just begun to appreciate. The disappearance of indigenous languages and traditions endangers key elements of our shared narrative, stripping away the rich heritage and understanding that connect us to both our past and future.

In an increasingly interconnected world, cultural exchange has become inevitable. As we share music, fashion, food, and traditions, the lines between appreciation and appropriation can become blurred. This reality has sparked discussions about cultural appropriation, bringing to the forefront an essential question: Where do we draw the line between honoring a culture and exploiting it?

Cultural appropriation is often defined as the unauthorized or inappropriate adoption of elements from one culture by members of another, usually without understanding or respecting the original context. Recent heated debates in Kenya illustrate this complexity. Many have criticized Kenyans for adopting Nigerian wedding attire, often perceived as more appealing, while neglecting their own rich cultural heritage. This trend raises important questions about identity and the value we place on our traditions. Are we losing touch with our roots in favor of what is trendy or aesthetically pleasing?

Moreover, the situation is intensified by the ingress of tourists who buy nomadic beads and other traditional crafts without understanding their cultural significance. While these items may be viewed as beautiful accessories, the commodification of such cultural artifacts can be seen as a form of cultural appropriation. This one-sided exchange often strips these items of their meanings, reducing them to mere fashion statements while ignoring the rich history and traditions they represent.

On the flip side, cultural appreciation involves a genuine respect and understanding of a culture, often rooted in meaningful engagement. It’s about learning, sharing, and celebrating cultural practices in a way that honors their origins. For example, participating in cultural festivals or learning traditional dances can foster mutual respect and understanding among different cultures.

But moving through these challenges is not always easy. Many people argue that cultural exchange is a natural part of human interaction. Music genres like jazz, rock, and hip-hop have roots in diverse cultures, and their evolution has been shaped by various influences. So, is it possible to appreciate and celebrate these influences without crossing into appropriation?

As we grapple with these problems, it’s crucial to listen and learn. Engaging with cultural practices should come with a willingness to understand their histories and significance. This means seeking out voices from the cultures we wish to appreciate and amplifying them, rather than speaking over them.

As we reflect on our own interactions with culture, we must consider the opportunities we have to initiate successful regional projects aimed at preventing the extinction of endangered languages and cultural practices. By striving for a minimum 25% increase in language proficiency and a 30% rise in cultural practice participation within local communities, we can make a meaningful impact.

One way to achieve this is by forming partnerships with educational and cultural institutions worldwide. These collaborations could lead to the integration of cultural preservation programs into their curricula and activities, engaging at least 1,000 students annually in cultural preservation efforts. With specific goals such as a 20% increase in student participation in cultural advocacy and a 15% rise in the number of cultural preservation projects initiated by students each year, we can empower the next generation to appreciate and protect their heritage.

In addition to educational partnerships, developing community engagement programs that partner with indigenous communities can further enhance our efforts. These initiatives can focus on documenting and revitalizing cultural practices and languages, measuring success through comprehensive documentation plans for each community, and initiating at least three revitalization projects per community. Progress can be reviewed through biannual reports and community feedback, ensuring that these efforts remain relevant and impactful.

Moreover, launching a global awareness campaign is essential to enhance public understanding of the importance of cultural preservation. This campaign aims to reach 1 million people through a combination of digital media—including social media and online ads—and educational events such as webinars and workshops. By monitoring campaign reach through digital analytics and event attendance records, along with quarterly evaluations, we can refine our strategies for effectively reaching our target audience and spreading our message.

Together, these initiatives can create a cohesive framework for promoting cultural preservation, fostering respect and understanding, and ultimately building bridges instead of walls in our increasingly global society.

So, this week, let’s reflect on our own interactions with culture. Are we genuinely appreciating or appropriating? How can we engage more mindfully with the diverse jumbles of traditions that enrich our lives? By fostering respect and understanding, we can navigate the fine line between cultural appreciation and appropriation—building bridges instead of walls in our increasingly global society.

Categories: News

Membership

IELA represents all educational settings, including independent and state schools, colleges and universities, charities, organisations, corporate companies and businesses in the UK and world-wide.

Find out more about Membership here.